When do you want it?
Added to your cart! Now choose how and when you'd like to get it.
You'll choose your pickup or delivery date in the cart before checkout.
Our Customer Favorites
Order for Pickup from our 75th Street Store
Cakes
Caramel
This is Diana Ross. The lead Supreme. Our number one cake. I let my grandmother leave the planet without learning how...
From $44.58
German Dark Chocolate
This is the Supreme who shows up in a tuxedo. Dark chocolate cake. Coconut-pecan frosting that took its time getting ...
From $53.48
Red Velvet
I revered the women in my community who made the red velvet cakes. They were goddesses to me, because of how wonderfu...
From $53.48
Lemon
Most of our cakes come from cake I loved as a kid. Rainbow sherbet. The little caramel bullets with the white center....
From $44.58
Yellow Chocolate
Yellow cake with chocolate frosting is the birthday cake most of us grew up on. So we don't get cute with it. We make...
From $44.58
Vanilla Cream & Carmel
The little caramel bullets with the white center. That's where this cake came from. I loved those as a kid. So we mak...
From $44.58
Pineapple Coconut
Craving a pineapple coconut cake — which was my choice for my birthday — I taught myself how to bake. Most of our cak...
From $53.48
Double Dark Chocolate
Some cakes flirt with chocolate. This one means it. Dark chocolate cake. Dark chocolate frosting. Rich without being ...
From $53.48
Turtle
Take the candy you used to sneak out of your grandmother's good dish. Make it a cake. Chocolate cake with caramel run...
From $53.48
Strawberry
Strawberry cake gets shortcuts taken with it more than almost any other cake. So we don't take them. Real strawberrie...
From $44.58
Rainbow Sherbet
I love rainbow sherbet, so we make a rainbow sherbet cake. Most of our cakes come from cake I loved as a kid. This is...
From $53.48
Pound Cakes
I revered the women in my community who made pound cakes. Pound cake is one of those cakes that doesn't hide. No fros...
From $44.58
Porgy & Bess
Two cakes that go together like the names they share. Yellow chocolate on one side. Red velvet on the other. Both cak...
From $44.58
Coconut
Coconut cake is one of those cakes that tells on a baker. If the coconut's stale, you can taste it. If the cake's dry...
From $53.48
OBAMA
Four layers, three of our finest cakes in one. Yellow, dark chocolate, and red velvet stacked tall, wrapped in real c...
$72.88
KAMALA
The Vice President came for the German Chocolate. In 2021, Vice President Kamala Harris came to Brown Sugar Bakery. L...
$65.00
Mini cupcakes
Mini Cup Cakes
Same cake. Smaller. Built for the room, the office, the party. Red velvet that earns its place — real cocoa, buttermi...
From $34.68
Mini Cup Cakes (48 count)
For when twenty-four won't get it done. Same red velvet — real cocoa, buttermilk tang, cream cheese frosting that kno...
From $68.28