773-570-7676 Get directions
Checking hours… 328 E 75th St, Chicago

Our Customer Favorites

Order for Pickup from our 75th Street Store

Cakes

Caramel Cake — 2 Layer (wholesale)

Caramel

Our number one cake and an award winner. Layers of moist yellow cake with a smooth, cooked caramel frosting — sweet, ...

From $44.58

German Chocolate - 4-Layer Cake

German Dark Chocolate

Contains Nuts Dark chocolate cake layers with traditional coconut-pecan frosting and a layer of caramel between the l...

From $53.48

Red Velvet - 4-Layer Cake

Red Velvet

Contains Nuts Red velvet cake with a hint of cocoa, wrapped in cream cheese frosting and topped with toasted pecans. ...

From $53.48

Lemon - 4-Layer Cake

Lemon

Tender yellow cake layers made with fresh lemon zest and lime in the cream cheese frosting. Available as a 2-layer or...

From $44.58

Yellow Chocolate - 4-Layer Cake

Yellow Chocolate

Tender yellow cake layers with rich chocolate frosting.Available as a 2-layer or 4-layer cake. Hand-frosted.

From $44.58

Vanilla Cream & Carmel - 4-Layer Cake

Vanilla Cream & Carmel

Yellow cake with vanilla cream cheese frosting and caramel. Available as a 2-layer or 4-layer cake. Hand-frosted.

From $44.58

Pineapple Coconut - 4-Layer Cake

Pineapple Coconut

Pineapple coconut cake: pineapple and coconut through the layers. Stephanie's own birthday cake, and the one that sta...

From $53.48

Double Dark Chocolate - 4-Layer Cake

Double Dark Chocolate

Chocolate cake layered with silky chocolate frosting.Available as a 2-layer or 4-layer cake. Hand-frosted.

From $53.48

Turtle - 4-Layer Cake

Turtle

Contains Nuts Yellow and Chocolate cake with chocolate frosting finished with caramel and pecans. Available as a 2-la...

From $53.48

Strawberry - 4-Layer Cake

Strawberry

Tender yellow cake layers made with real strawberries blended with strawberry cream cheese frosting. Available as a 2...

From $44.58

Rainbow Sherbet

Rainbow Sherbet

Layers flavored like rainbow sherbet: orange, raspberry, and lime.Available as a 2-layer or 4-layer cake. Hand-frosted.

From $53.48

Pound Cakes

Pound Cakes

Butter pound cake, baked in a bundt. Available in Plain, Carmel, Lemon, and Vanilla Cream Carmel.

From $44.58

Porgy & Bess - 4-Layer Cake

Porgy & Bess

Yellow cake with carmel filling, chocolate frosting topped with carmel.  Available as a 2-layer or 4-layer cake. Hand...

From $44.58

Coconut - 4-Layer

Coconut

Coconut cake with cream cheese frosting, covered in coconut.Available as a 2-layer or 4-layer cake. Hand-frosted.

From $53.48

OBAMA - 4-Layer Cake

OBAMA

Contains Nuts Three cakes in one: red velvet, chocolate, and yellow cake layers with vanilla cream cheese frosting, f...

$72.88

KAMALA

KAMALA

Contains Nuts An 8-inch cake made in tribute to Vice President Harris's 2021 visit to the bakery. Chocolate cake fill...

$65.00

Pudding

1/2 Pan Banana Pudding

1/2 Pan Banana Pudding

Half-pan banana pudding: vanilla custard, bananas, and vanilla wafers, layered.Built for a table, not a plate.

$66.88

Pies

Sweet Potato Pie (wholesale)

Sweet Potato Pies

9-inch sweet potato pie made with real sweet potatoes and warm spice in a butter crust.

$31.08

Mini cupcakes

Mini Cupcakes (wholesale)

Mini Cup Cakes

Mini cupcakes, hand-frosted, 24 or 48 to a pack.Choose Red Velvet, Red Velvet (No Nuts), Chocolate Variety Pack, Yell...

From $34.68

Mini Cupcakes (wholesale)

Mini Cup Cakes (48 count)

Mini cupcakes, hand-frosted, 48 to a pack.Choose Red Velvet, Red Velvet (No Nuts), Chocolate Variety Pack, Yellow Cak...

From $68.28

A Brown Sugar Bakery team member handing a pickup order across the counter
Customers paying for their order at the Brown Sugar Bakery counter
Strawberry-frosted cupcakes glowing in the bakery case
  • Ach Direct Debit
  • Amazon
  • Amazon
  • American Express
  • Apple Pay
  • Discover
  • Mastercard
  • PayPal
  • Visa

© 2026 Brown Sugar Bakery Chicago | Powered by Shopify